|
hat do architect Michael Graves and tennis star Andre Agassi, powerhouses in
their respective fields, have in common? Both are redefining Universal
Design, and in the process are impacting not just guidelines, but aesthetics.
The concept of Universal Design focuses on designing all
products and environments to be as usable as possible by as many people as
possible regardless of age, ability, or situation. Since the government
passed the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) in 1990 (inspired by disabled
Vietnam veterans), practically every conceivable experience from sitting on a
toilet to crossing the road to reading directions has been regulated by means of
measurement. The government stipulates, for example, heights for toilets
in school bathrooms to best suit the grades that use them.
Compliance with all these humanitarian rules is a costly
business. Elevators, for example, are required in all public spaces so
that physically-challenged people can go wherever they want, be they infirm
elderly people or those suffering from temporary mobility limitations due to
injury—not just the wheelchair-bound. Designer and restaurant tycoon Sir
Terence Conran recollects that he spent about $40,000 extra per restaurant on
complying with accessibility standards.
Even when a facility is in compliance with ADA regulations,
many accessibility limitations still exist. Michael Graves experienced a
tragedy earlier this year when a viral infection paralyzed him from the waist
down. His friends expected he would turn his creative attention to
redesigning his wheelchair, but what really needs attention, he says, is “the
stupid room”. His list of design failures in hospital patient rooms is
long: the sinks are too low to allow the wheelchair arms to slide under them;
the shelves are so deep he cannot access anything toward the back; there are
only two drawers within his reach; the window blinds are too high and on the
wrong side.
One doesn’t have to be in a wheelchair to encounter
everyday products that do not meet the standards implied by Universal Design.
As advancing age impairs vision, directions and labels on household items and
appliances can become impossible to read. Incredibly, hearing aids do not
necessarily help the hearing impaired to hear better—they just turn up the
decibel level of everything, so that it’s often harder to hear what you want to
hear. And arthritic elderly people may grapple with safety devices on pill
bottles designed to prevent access by children who are probably not living with
them.
While ADA laws were the first step to addressing serious
accessibility issues, strict dimension guidelines can actually limit new design
concepts, ultimately hindering usability. Fortunately, a redefinition of
Universal Design is beginning in ways that counteract the present norm of simply
adhering to a set of measurements. The designers at Berlin studio 7.5 who
just produced the new, brilliant Mirra chair for Herman Miller have reframed the
Universal Design curricula for the German universities at which they teach.
They call the subject “user interface”, and they aim to banish, for example, all
written documents explaining how to use a product. Instead, they maintain,
“The product responds to the user’s needs by feel.”
Tennis star Andre Agassi is extending the concept of
Universal Design to the educational field, an area of critical concern in light
of recent school tragedies. The Andre Agassi College Preparatory Academy
located in Agassi’s home town of Las Vegas, Nevada, is a charter school that
brings order and hope to a district with the highest crime rate in the city.
Its record of success with children at risk demonstrates that conventional
standards of Universal Design in schools should reach far beyond following
measurement codes if students are to be motivated to learn, respect property and
human lives, and develop self-esteem. Mindfully focused on giving back to
the community, Agassi simply asked his award-winning architects Carpenter
Sellers to come up with the best-designed school in the country. There are
no deadly, bland corridors here, or ugly asphalt open spaces. All carpeted
classrooms have thoughtfully-positioned daylighting, and each is painted a
different color, with furniture to match. The corridors reflect a rainbow
of colors on the floors. The list goes on: a music room for the choir; an
art studio with a roll-up door so that work can go on outside; science
laboratories as sophisticated as any Ivy League college. With dedication
and philanthropy, Agassi has set a model for a new interpretation of Universal
Design in the school system—such a shining example that recently it was written
into the Congressional Record.
Los Angeles architectural firm Pica + Sullivan, whose
principals Joe Pica and Maureen Sullivan are parents of an autistic child, have
also raised the bar in school design, concentrating on “places between the
classrooms, where most learning takes place”. Umbrella’d outdoor
cafeterias, ponds for studying biology, and landscaping that promotes community
feeling show how design that fulfills more than just bureaucratic guidelines can
make all the difference.
Actor Paul Newman, founder of the Hole in the Wall Gang
Camp Association for children with special needs, sets an example of design
excellence in each of his numerous projects. The Painted Turtle, Newman’s
sixth camp and the first on the West Coast, is being designed by Michael
Palladino of Richard Meier & Partners. The camps allow children with
serious illnesses to “just be kids” while enjoying the company of other
children. A magical transformation happens at these camps.
Otherwise-limited children can become actors, swimmers, athletes, horseback
riders, and fishers. A 15-year-old with sickle cell disease said, “I fight
hard all winter so that I can have a summer of being a normal kid. And I
keep those memories all year.” An 11-year-old with cancer summarized the
key to the camp’s success: “If a kid is normal, they want to be treated special.
If a kid has a disease, they want to be treated normal.” This, too, has
become the key principle of Universal Design. Rather than merely managing
illness and disability, creating environments that promote and enable wellness,
in every sense, is the focus of the future.
Beverly Russell is an international author, educator and
certified labyrinth facilitator based in Los Angeles.
|